At one time, perhaps the most apocryphally accepted beginning and end "book-ends" on the spectrum of educational needs were "giftedness" and the "learning-disabled." When one considers the "gifted" child, they anticipate a high-achieving, bright, and enthusiastic student--eager to learn and understand. They attribute giftedness to ambitiousness, creativity, and of course, endless intelligence. However, this notion is anything but true. In fact, "giftedness"--in its truest form--is not defined by or a term necessarily associated with the need for less instruction.
And here's the real kicker: in terms of emotional and educational problems, the trends of "gifted" children more closely resemble the trends of "learning-disabled" children. In fact, both labels often neglect to acknowledge the phenomenon of twice-exceptional children. Or, children who have both moderate or severe attention, emotional, and learning problems. Often, these children's exceptional strengths and challenges might be overlooked as "averageness" as they cancel one another out. Consider the following scenarios, courtesy of understood.org:
Tessa is a bright, insightful, and enthusiastic fourth grader who is reading at a 12th-grade level. At the same time, she can't pass spelling tests, and writing is a huge struggle.
Jamie is 16. He knows everything about the Civil War, writes beautifully, and can talk endlessly about politics. Yet he needs a calculator to help him with even the most basic math. And he couldn't tie his shoes until he was in seventh grade.
Steven Spielberg is one of the most successful filmmakers of all time, but reading has been a lifelong struggle for him because he has dyslexia.
This world--especially the educational world--is no place for savants. Finding, and more importantly, nurturing exceptional talent has become near impossible as Common Core and other conformity-promoting educational structures have become more and more prevalent. With more rules and restrictions, exceptional students are often forced under labels such as "gifted" or "learning-disabled," when in reality, the two are more closely-related than we could ever imagine.
To some degree, we all experience the social and emotional challenges of twice-exceptional children. We all experience frustration, low self-esteem, and social isolation. However, those placed under umbrella terms such as "gifted" or "learning-disabled" are often plagued by these challenges.
The human conversation is one of complete connectedness. There is no definite end to our ability or disability as a species. Defining "book-ends" will only hurt us.